Behr Toasty Gray vs SW Agreeable Gray: What’s the Difference?

When searching for the perfect warm neutral paint color, it’s easy to get stuck comparing two similar versatile shades from Behr and Sherwin Williams. Popular choices Behr Toasty Gray N320-2 and Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray SW 7029 appear very alike at first glance. But what really differentiates these two beautiful, subtle neutrals?

In this guide, we’ll analyze Toasty Gray vs Agreeable Gray in-depth to help you determine the ideal neutral paint for your home. We’ll look at undertones, light reflectance, real-life photos, room pairings and more.

Let’s dive in!

Table of Contents

Key Differences Between Toasty Gray and Agreeable Gray

Before getting into the nitty gritty, here is an overview of the main differences between Behr’s Toasty Gray and Sherwin Williams’ Agreeable Gray:

Undertones – Toasty Gray is a warm taupe, Agreeable Gray is warm beige
Light Reflectance – Toasty Gray has an LRV of 61, Agreeable Gray has an LRV of 60
Use – Toasty Gray suits rustic farmhouse styles, Agreeable Gray fits traditional decor
Rooms – Toasty Gray excels in living rooms, Agreeable Gray shines in bedrooms
Availability – Toasty Gray in all finishes, Agreeable Gray in all sheens

Now let’s explore Toasty Gray and Agreeable Gray more thoroughly.

Behr Toasty Gray N320-2

With its subtle warm taupe appearance, Behr Toasty Gray N320-2 creates an understated backdrop well-suited for rustic farmhouse styles. This versatile neutral works across casual spaces.

Here are some details about Toasty Gray:

LRV: 61
Undertones: Warm taupe
Finish: Available in all finishes
Rooms: Living rooms, dining rooms, bedrooms, offices
Pairs Well With: Earth tones, wood tones, black accents

Toasty Gray is a relaxed, dusty mushroom taupe with faint gray undertones. In certain lights it can take on a weathered clay feel. The welcoming neutral has down-to-earth appeal.

The 61 light reflectance value prevents the shade from feeling too dark or drab. Toasty Gray strikes a cozy yet bright balance suitable for most rooms.

This versatile neutral complements rustic, organic color combinations. Popular Toasty Gray pairings include:

Behr Roasted Chestnut
Black iron accents
Distressed wood finishes
Natural linen and cotton textures

While suitable anywhere at home, Toasty Gray truly excels in these casual spaces:

Living Rooms
Dining Rooms
Bedrooms
Offices
Entryways

Toasty Gray’s earthy warmth helps create a welcoming, farmhouse feel perfect as an all-over home color. Use it to allow wooden accents to shine.

Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray SW 7029

With its warm beige appearance, Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray SW 7029 creates an understated backdrop well-suited for accentuating traditional decor. This versatile neutral works in both formal and casual spaces.

Here are some details about Agreeable Gray:

LRV: 60
Undertones: Warm beige
Finish: Available in all sheens
Rooms: Bedrooms, living rooms, dining rooms, offices
Pairs Well With: Blues, blacks, wood tones

Agreeable Gray is a relaxed, soft beige-influenced gray with faint tan undertones. In certain lights it can read as a weathered mushroom. The welcoming neutral has traditional appeal.

The 60 light reflectance value prevents the shade from feeling too dark or drab. Agreeable Gray strikes a cozy yet bright balance suitable for most rooms.

This versatile neutral complements both cool and warm accents nicely. Popular Agreeable Gray color pairings include:

Sherwin Williams Pure White
Sherwin Williams Tricorn Black
Black accent pieces
Walnut wood finishes
White trim and mouldings

While suitable anywhere at home, Agreeable Gray truly excels in these spaces:

Bedrooms
Living Rooms
Dining Rooms
Offices
Libraries

Agreeable Gray’s warmth helps create a welcoming, traditional feel perfect as an all-over home color. Use it to allow bold colors to stand out.

Comparing Toasty Gray vs Agreeable Gray

Now that we’ve examined Toasty Gray and Agreeable Gray independently, let’s directly compare them:

Light Reflectance

Toasty Gray and Agreeable Gray have similar LRVs of 61 and 60 respectively. They will appear nearly identical in brightness.

Undertones

Here’s where the main difference lies. Toasty Gray is a warm taupe, while Agreeable Gray is a warm beige-influenced gray.

Use & Rooms

Toasty Gray’s earthiness excels in rustic living rooms. Agreeable Gray’s warmth is perfect for cozy bedrooms.

Availability

Toasty Gray comes in all finishes from flat to eggshell. Agreeable Gray comes in any sheen from matte to gloss.

Paint Color	Toasty Gray N320-2	Agreeable Gray SW 7029
LRV	61	60
Undertones	Warm taupe	Warm beige
Use	Rustic styles	Traditional decor
Finishes	All finishes	All sheens
Style	Farmhouse	Traditional

Real-Life Photos: Toasty Gray vs Agreeable Gray

Let’s look at real-life photos to better visualize the differences between Toasty Gray and Agreeable Gray:

Behr Toasty Gray

Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray

While they can overlap, Toasty Gray generally appears more brown, earthy and casual than the warm gray tone of Agreeable Gray. But lighting affects their look.

Should I Choose Toasty Gray or Agreeable Gray?

So how do you decide between Behr’s Toasty Gray or Sherwin Williams’ Agreeable Gray for your home? Here are a few tips:

Choose Toasty Gray N320-2 if you want:

A warm, earthy neutral taupe
A versatile color suitable for rustic farmhouse styles
A cozy feel for living rooms and dining rooms
To allow wood tones to stand out

Choose Agreeable Gray SW 7029 if you want:

A warm, beige-influenced light gray
A sophisticated neutral for bedrooms and offices
A versatile color that works with traditional decor
A soft, airy backdrop

Get samples of both Toasty Gray and Agreeable Gray. Paint large test sections to view in different lighting at various times of day. This gives you the best sense of how the undertones read in your environment.

You can also try pairing them with decor you already have to visualize the look. Both offer beautiful warm neutral tones for varied styles.

Ideal Room Pairings

Here are some rooms that are especially well-suited to Toasty Gray and Agreeable Gray paint colors:

Behr Toasty Gray

Living Rooms
Dining Rooms
Bedrooms
Offices
Entryways

Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray

Bedrooms
Living Rooms
Dining Rooms
Offices
Libraries

While both neutrals work well throughout the home, the above applications make optimal use of their unique strengths.

Decorating Ideas and Color Pairings

On their own, Toasty Gray and Agreeable Gray create peaceful backdrops. Complement them with other colors and materials for gorgeous spaces:

Toasty Gray N320-2 Pairings

Behr Roasted Chestnut
Black iron accents
Distressed wood finishes
Natural linen and cotton textures

Agreeable Gray SW 7029 Pairings

Sherwin Williams Pure White
Sherwin Williams Tricorn Black
Black accent pieces
Walnut wood finishes
White trim and mouldings

Toasty Gray vs Agreeable Gray – Which is Better?

So which warm neutral paint color is better for your home – Toasty Gray or Agreeable Gray?

Consider Toasty Gray N320-2 if you want:

A warm, earthy neutral taupe
A versatile color suitable for rustic farmhouse styles
A cozy feel for living rooms and dining rooms
To allow wood tones to stand out

Consider Agreeable Gray SW 7029 if you want:

A warm, beige-influenced light gray
A sophisticated neutral for bedrooms and offices
A versatile color that works with traditional decor
A soft, airy backdrop

While Toasty Gray offers rustic warmth, Agreeable Gray provides refined elegance.

Get samples before deciding. Either beautiful neutral you choose will suit your home perfectly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Still trying to decide between Toasty Gray or Agreeable Gray? Here are answers to some common questions:

What are the main differences between Toasty Gray and Agreeable Gray?

The main differences are their undertones and suitability for varied spaces. Toasty Gray is a warm, earthy taupe while Agreeable Gray is a more refined, beige-gray.