Searching for the perfect warm greige paint color? Popular options Collingwood OC-28 from Benjamin Moore and Agreeable Gray SW 7029 from Sherwin Williams appear very similar at first glance. But what really sets these two gorgeous greiges apart?
In this guide, we’ll compare Collingwood vs Agreeable Gray in-depth to help you determine the ideal warm greige paint for your home. We’ll look at undertones, light reflectance, real-life photos, room pairings and more.
Let’s dive in!
Table of Contents
Key Differences Between Collingwood and Agreeable Gray
Before getting into the nitty gritty, here is an overview of the main differences between Benjamin Moore’s Collingwood and Sherwin Williams’ Agreeable Gray:
- Undertones – Collingwood is a truer greige, Agreeable Gray leans warm beige
- Light Reflectance – Collingwood has an LRV of 61.52, Agreeable Gray has an LRV of 60
- Use – Collingwood suits modern and traditional styles, Agreeable Gray excels in farmhouses
- Rooms – Collingwood shines in living rooms, Agreeable Gray works everywhere
- Availability – Both come in all sheens
Now let’s explore Collingwood and Agreeable Gray more thoroughly.
Benjamin Moore Collingwood OC-28
With its adaptable greige appearance, Benjamin Moore Collingwood OC-28 creates a versatile backdrop that works across varied styles and spaces. This harmonious greige gracefully transitions from room to room.
Here are some details about Collingwood:
- LRV: 61.52
- Undertones: Greige
- Finish: Available in all sheens
- Rooms: Living rooms, bedrooms, kitchens, baths, offices
- Pairs Well With: Crisp whites, warm woods, black, metallics
Collingwood is a relaxed tannish greige that maintains the same muted tone across lighting conditions. The adaptable color has widespread appeal.
The 61.52 light reflectance value gives Collingwood flexibility without seeming too dark or stark. It’s subdued without feeling flat or gloomy.
As a versatile greige, Collingwood complements both cool and warm palettes nicely. Popular Collingwood color combinations include:
- Benjamin Moore Simply White
- Sherwin Williams Repose Gray
- Black metal fixtures and accents
- White oak and walnut wood tones
- Polished brass hardware
Collingwood excels as an adaptable, livable greige that effortlessly connects rooms with varied styles. It provides a soothing, welcoming backdrop for bolder colors and textures to shine.
Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray SW 7029
With its warm, inviting neutrality, Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray SW 7029 creates a versatile backdrop with farmhouse appeal. This welcoming greige works everywhere throughout your home.
Here are some details about Agreeable Gray:
- LRV: 60
- Undertones: Light beige
- Finish: Available in all sheens
- Rooms: Anywhere
- Pairs Well With: All colors
Agreeable Gray is a cheerful but relaxed beige-leaning greige with a faint yellow undertone. It maintains versatility across different lighting conditions.
The 60 light reflectance value gives Agreeable Gray’s soft neutrality an adaptable brightness perfect for any room.
As an easygoing greige, Agreeable Gray complements almost any color scheme or style. Popular combinations include:
- Bright whites like Chantilly Lace
- Bold colors like Naval or Spicy Red
- Natural wood tones and stains
- Black iron fixtures and hardware
- Varied trim colors like red or navy
With its versatile warmth and flexibility, Agreeable Gray looks beautiful anywhere at home. It works well in every room creating a welcoming farmhouse retreat.
Comparing Collingwood vs Agreeable Gray
Now that we’ve looked at Collingwood and Agreeable Gray independently, let’s directly compare them:
Light Reflectance
Collingwood and Agreeable Gray have different LRVs of 61.52 and 60 respectively. Agreeable Gray reads lighter.
Undertones
Collingwood is a truer greige, while Agreeable Gray leans warm beige. Their subtle undertone difference sets them apart.
Use & Rooms
Collingwood’s versatility excels in living rooms and beyond. Agreeable Gray suits any space.
Availability
Both Collingwood and Agreeable Gray come in any sheen.
Collingwood vs Agreeable Gray Comparison Chart
| Paint Color | Collingwood OC-28 | Agreeable Gray SW 7029 |
|---|---|---|
| LRV | 61.52 | 60 |
| Undertones | Greige | Beige |
| Use | Adaptable neutral | Versatile neutral |
| Finishes | All sheens | All sheens |
| Style | Modern, traditional, transitional | Farmhouse, traditional, transitional |
Real-Life Photos: Collingwood vs Agreeable Gray
Let’s look at real-life photos to better visualize the subtle differences between Collingwood and Agreeable Gray:
Benjamin Moore Collingwood
Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray
While quite similar, Agreeable Gray reads warmer and more beige compared to the greyer mutedness of Collingwood. Lighting affects their tones.
Should I Choose Collingwood or Agreeable Gray?
So how do you decide between Benjamin Moore’s Collingwood or Sherwin Williams’ Agreeable Gray for your space? Here are a few tips:
Choose Collingwood OC-28 if you want:
- A true greige that adapts across rooms
- A moodier, more muted shade
- A flexible backdrop for varied styles
- Slightly less warmth
Choose Agreeable Gray SW 7029 if you want:
- A light beige-based greige
- A warm, welcoming farmhouse feel
- A versatile neutral everywhere
- Maximum livability
Get large samples of both paint colors. Paint swatches on walls viewing during different times of day. This gives you the best sense of their warmth and depth.
You can also move decor next to the swatches to visualize the overall look. While similar, these two greiges suit different aesthetics.
Ideal Room Pairings
Here are some rooms especially well-suited to Collingwood and Agreeable Gray paint colors:
Benjamin Moore Collingwood
- Living Rooms
- Bedrooms
- Dining Rooms
- Offices
- Studies
Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray
- Living Rooms
- Bedrooms
- Bathrooms
- Kitchens
- Hallways and Staircases
While both work well throughout the home, the above applications optimize each greige’s unique strengths.
Decorating Ideas and Color Pairings
On their own, Collingwood and Agreeable Gray make beautiful neutral backdrops. Complement them with bold colors and natural materials:
Collingwood OC-28 Pairings
- Crisp bright whites
- Modern black and metal
- Polished brass hardware
- White oak and walnut woods
- Navy blue accents
Agreeable Gray SW 7029 Pairings
- Chantilly Lace white
- Bold reds and blues
- Natural wood tones and stains
- Black iron fixtures
- Vibrant trim colors
Collingwood vs Agreeable Gray – Which is Better?
So which greige paint color is better for your home – Collingwood or Agreeable Gray?
Choose Benjamin Moore Collingwood OC-28 if you want:
- A true muted greige
- Adaptability across rooms
- A moodier, more subtle backdrop
- Modern or traditional appeal
Choose Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray SW 7029 if you prefer:
- A light beige-greige with warmth
- A welcoming farmhouse feel
- Maximum versatility and livability
- A failsafe neutral
While comparable, Collingwood is more adaptable and Agreeable Gray warmer. Get samples before deciding. Either beautiful neutral greige you choose is sure to suit your home beautifully.
Frequently Asked Questions
Still trying to decide between Collingwood or Agreeable Gray? Here are answers to some common questions:
What is the main difference between Collingwood and Agreeable Gray?
The main difference is Collingwood is a truer greige while Agreeable Gray leans slightly beige. Collingwood is more muted and modern.
Does Agreeable Gray come in flat finish?
Yes, one reason Agreeable Gray is so popular is it’s available in any sheen from ultra flat matte to high gloss.
Can you use Collingwood in a bathroom?
Definitely, Collingwood’s muted greige tone would work wonderfully in a bathroom paired with crisp white trim and bronze fixtures for a soothing spa-like feel.
Is Agreeable Gray suitable for southern exposure?
Yes, Agreeable Gray’s warmth and 60 LRV allow it to handle abundant southern sunlight. Add window treatments to balance light if needed.
What colors complement Collingwood walls?
Collingwood looks gorgeous with crisp whites, modern black and metal accents, brass hardware, white oak and walnut wood tones, and navy blue focal points.
