BM Edgecomb Gray vs SW Agreeable Gray: What’s the Difference?

When searching for the perfect neutral gray paint color, two top options to consider are Benjamin Moore Edgecomb Gray HC-173 and Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray SW 7029. Both offer beautiful, versatile grays that work well across many design styles. But what’s the difference between Edgecomb Gray and Agreeable Gray? And how do you choose between them?

In this guide, we’ll analyze Edgecomb Gray vs Agreeable Gray in depth. We’ll look at undertones, light reflectance values (LRV), real-life photos, and ideal room applications. Let’s dive in to determine whether warm Edgecomb Gray or cooler Agreeable Gray is the best gray paint color for your home’s interior.

Table of Contents

Key Differences Between Edgecomb Gray and Agreeable Gray

Before diving into specifics, here are the main differences between Benjamin Moore Edgecomb Gray HC-173 and Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray SW 7029 at a glance:

Undertones – Edgecomb Gray has green undertones, Agreeable Gray has purple undertones
LRV – Edgecomb Gray has an LRV of 63.09, Agreeable Gray has an LRV of 60
Use – Edgecomb Gray complements traditional styles, Agreeable Gray suits modern spaces
Rooms – Edgecomb Gray excels in cozy rooms, Agreeable Gray in open concepts

Now let’s explore Edgecomb Gray and Agreeable Gray more closely.

Benjamin Moore Edgecomb Gray HC-173

A bestselling neutral paint color, Edgecomb Gray HC-173 by Benjamin Moore is a warm, inviting medium gray that creates a relaxed backdrop. This adaptable color complements styles from modern to farmhouse.

Here are some details about Edgecomb Gray:

LRV: 63.09
Undertones: Green with brown tones
Finish: Available in all sheens
Rooms: Bedrooms, living rooms, offices
Color Pairings: Tans, browns, blues

With distinct green undertones infused with subtle brown, Edgecomb Gray has a natural, earthy appearance. Depending on lighting it can read as a soft sage green-gray or deeper charcoal gray with greenish cast. This adaptability makes Edgecomb Gray highly versatile.

At 63.09 light reflectance, Edgecomb Gray reflects enough light for most rooms without being too bright. The organic nature gives Edgecomb Gray a cozy warmth perfect for bedrooms and relaxed spaces.

Edgecomb Gray works well across many interior design styles. Use it to create a casual, welcoming backdrop for spaces including:

Bedrooms
Living Rooms
Offices/Studies
Dining Rooms
Bathrooms

Some colors that coordinate beautifully with Edgecomb Gray are:

Benjamin Moore White Dove
Benjamin Moore Hale Navy
Benjamin Moore Wythe Blue
Benjamin Moore Desert Twilight

Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray SW 7029

A bestselling neutral paint color, Agreeable Gray SW 7029 by Sherwin Williams is a versatile, adaptive light gray that works across many styles. This chameleon-like color shifts in different lighting.

Here are some details about Agreeable Gray:

LRV: 60
Undertones: Purple-gray
Finish: Available in all sheens
Rooms: Whole home, especially open concept living areas
Pairings: Blues, greens, wood tones

Featuring distinct purple-gray undertones, Agreeable Gray has a slightly dusty, hazy appearance. In some lights the purple is more noticeable, while in others it reads as a clean medium neutral gray. This makes it highly versatile.

With a 60 light reflectance value, Agreeable Gray reflects ample light to keep open concept rooms feeling airy. Yet it has enough depth to provide pleasing contrast against trim, cabinets, and ceilings.

Use Agreeable Gray SW 7029 to create a relaxed, welcoming backdrop for a wide range of interior design styles. This gorgeous neutral gray excels in these room applications:

Living Rooms
Dining Rooms
Bathrooms
Open Concept Kitchens
Family Rooms

Some colors that pair beautifully with Agreeable Gray include:

Benjamin Moore Simply White
Sherwin Williams Sea Salt
Benjamin Moore Rain
Natural wood stains

Comparing Edgecomb Gray vs Agreeable Gray

Now that we’ve looked at Edgecomb Gray and Agreeable Gray paint colors individually, let’s compare them directly:

Light Reflectance

Agreeable Gray is noticeably lighter than Edgecomb Gray, with LRVs of 60 vs 63.09 respectively. Agreeable Gray will make a space feel more open.

Undertones

Edgecomb Gray has warm green undertones, while Agreeable Gray has cooler purple undertones. Edgecomb Gray feels cozy, Agreeable Gray serene.

Use

The earthy warmth of Edgecomb Gray suits relaxed traditional designs. Agreeable Gray’s coolness complements sleek modern spaces.

Rooms

Edgecomb Gray’s coziness excels in smaller bedrooms and offices. Agreeable Gray’s airy clarity shines best in open concept kitchens and living areas.

Paint Finish

Both Edgecomb Gray and Agreeable Gray come in any sheen from matte to high gloss.

Pairings

Edgecomb Gray coordinates well with tans, browns, blues and cream. Agreeable Gray pairs nicely with grays, greens, blues and brass.

Edgecomb Gray vs Agreeable Gray Comparison Chart

Here is an overview comparison of key differences between Benjamin Moore Edgecomb Gray HC-173 and Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray SW 7029:

Paint Color	Edgecomb Gray HC-173	Agreeable Gray SW 7029
LRV	63.09	60
Undertones	Green with brown	Purple gray
Use	Traditional, relaxed	Modern, contemporary
Rooms	Bedrooms, offices	Open concept living areas
Sheens	All finishes	All finishes
Pairings	Tans, browns, blues, cream	Grays, greens, blues, brass

Real Life Photos: Edgecomb Gray vs Agreeable Gray

To give a sense of how Edgecomb Gray and Agreeable Gray compare in real spaces, let’s look at real life photos of the paint colors:

Edgecomb Gray HC-173

Agreeable Gray SW 7029

In real world spaces, Edgecomb Gray generally appears deeper and greener compared to the lighter, cooler Agreeable Gray. But different lighting can impact their look. Overall, Edgecomb Gray feels warmer and Agreeable Gray more serene.

Should I Choose Edgecomb Gray or Agreeable Gray?

So how do you decide between Benjamin Moore Edgecomb Gray or Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray for your home? Here are a few tips:

Consider Edgecomb Gray HC-173 if you want:

A green-gray with natural, organic earthiness
Cozy warmth perfect for bedrooms
To complement traditional and boho styles
To coordinate with tans, browns, blues and cream

Consider Agreeable Gray SW 7029 if you want:

A light-medium gray with cool purple undertones
An airy, hazy backdrop for modern styles
Excellent versatility for open concept spaces
A soft alternative to harsher whites and grays

To choose, get large paint samples and view in your actual space, at different times and lighting. See how the undertones come across and affect the mood. Also compare colors alongside your décor.

While both are beautiful neutrals, Edgecomb Gray fits cozier traditional rooms and Agreeable Gray modern open floor plans. Select the one aligned with your goals!

Best Rooms for Edgecomb Gray and Agreeable Gray

Here are rooms that tend to be particularly well suited to Edgecomb Gray HC-173 and Agreeable Gray SW 7029:

Edgecomb Gray HC-173

Bedrooms
Offices
Living Rooms
Dining Rooms
Libraries

Agreeable Gray SW 7029

Living Rooms
Kitchens
Bathrooms
Open Floor Plans
Dining Rooms

While both can work anywhere, the above applications maximize the strengths of Edgecomb Gray’s coziness and Agreeable Gray’s airy adaptability.

Design Ideas Using Edgecomb Gray and Agreeable Gray

On their own, Edgecomb Gray and Agreeable Gray create simple backdrops. Use colors, textures and décor to make complete room designs:

Edgecomb Gray Color Pairings

Benjamin Moore White Dove (trim/ceiling)
Benjamin Moore Kendall Charcoal (accent wall)
Light oak wood floors
Navy blue and cream textiles

Agreeable Gray Color Pairings

Benjamin Moore Chantilly Lace (trim/ceiling)
Brass lighting fixtures
Gray, navy and tan textiles
White cabinetry

Edgecomb Gray vs Agreeable Gray: Which is Better for Your Home?

Is cozy Edgecomb Gray or airy Agreeable Gray the better neutral paint color for your space? It depends on your goals and style:

Consider Edgecomb Gray if you want:

A green-influenced gray with natural warmth
Cozy ambiance perfect for bedrooms
To complement traditional, boho aesthetics
A color that pairs well with tans, browns, blues

Consider Agreeable Gray if you want:

A light-medium gray with subtle cool purple tones
An airy, tranquil mood for modern styles
Adaptable color for open concept spaces
A soft alternative to harsh whites and grays

Edgecomb Gray excels in smaller cozy bedrooms and traditional homes. Agreeable Gray shines in airy open concept kitchens, living rooms, and contemporary spaces.

Be sure to get large in-home paint samples before deciding. Both are stunning versatile grays – choose the one that fulfills your goals!