Searching for the perfect rich navy paint color? It’s easy to get stuck comparing two similar dramatic shades from Benjamin Moore like Old Navy 2063-10 and Hale Navy HC-154. At first glance they appear nearly identical. But what really differentiates these two deep navy blues?
In this guide, we’ll analyze Old Navy vs Hale Navy thoroughly to help determine the ideal navy paint color for your home. We’ll look at undertones, light reflectance, real-life photos, room pairings and more.
Let’s dive in!
Table of Contents
Key Differences Between Old Navy and Hale Navy
Before getting into the details, here is an overview of the main differences between Benjamin Moore’s Old Navy and Hale Navy:
- Undertones – Old Navy is a green-leaning navy, Hale Navy is a truer indigo
- Light Reflectance – Old Navy has an LRV of 5.13, Hale Navy has an LRV of 8.36
- Use – Old Navy suits contemporary and traditional styles, Hale Navy works across the board
- Rooms – Old Navy excels in dining rooms, Hale Navy shines as an accent
- Availability – Both come in all sheens
Now let’s explore Old Navy and Hale Navy more thoroughly.
Benjamin Moore Old Navy 2063-10
With its classic navy blue appearance, Benjamin Moore Old Navy 2063-10 creates a refined backdrop well-suited for varied styles and spaces. This versatile color works in both contemporary and traditional homes.
Here are some key details about Old Navy:
- LRV: 5.13
- Undertones: Navy blue with faint green
- Finish: Available in all sheens
- Rooms: Dining rooms, bedrooms, studies, baths
- Pairs Well With: Light blues, warm woods, white
Old Navy is a rich green-tinted navy that appears more blue in dim lighting. The timeless color has broad appeal.
The 5.13 light reflectance value gives this shade dramatic depth without overwhelming. Old Navy strikes a stately yet relaxed balance suitable for most rooms.
This flexible navy blue complements both cool and warm accents. Popular Old Navy color combinations include:
- Benjamin Moore Edgecomb Gray
- Benjamin Moore Simply White
- Maple and walnut wood tones
- Brass and chrome metals
- Crisp white trim
While suitable throughout the home, Old Navy truly excels in these key spaces:
- Dining Rooms
- Studies
- Bathrooms
- Bedrooms
- Kitchens
Old Navy’s aqua undertones help create an elegant, soothing setting. Use it to establish a refined backdrop day or night.
Benjamin Moore Hale Navy HC-154
With its deep indigo appearance, Benjamin Moore Hale Navy HC-154 adds bold, dramatic contrast as an accent color. This versatile navy blue works across styles from modern to traditional.
Here are some key details about Hale Navy:
- LRV: 8.36
- Undertones: Navy blue
- Finish: Available in all sheens
- Rooms: Accent walls, small baths, kitchens
- Pairs Well With: Beiges, yellows, greys, woods
Hale Navy is a rich, saturated navy that maintains a consistent bold indigo look across lighting conditions. The dramatic color makes a statement.
The 8.36 light reflectance value gives this shade intense depth as an accent. Hale Navy packs strong visual impact.
This flexible navy blue pairs nicely with lighter neutrals. Popular Hale Navy color combinations include:
- Benjamin Moore Chantilly Lace
- Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter
- Soft greys and tans
- White trim and natural wood
- Brass hardware
While bold for an all-over color, Hale Navy excels when used strategically in these spaces:
- Accent Walls
- Small Bathrooms
- Kitchens
- Dining Rooms
- Entryways
Hale Navy’s dramatic saturation makes colors and textures pop. Use it deliberately to add striking contrast.
Comparing Old Navy vs Hale Navy
Now that we’ve examined Old Navy and Hale Navy independently, let’s directly compare them:
Light Reflectance
Old Navy and Hale Navy have different LRVs of 5.13 and 8.36 respectively. Old Navy will read slightly lighter.
Undertones
Old Navy leans green, while Hale Navy is a truer indigo navy. Their undertones set them apart.
Use & Rooms
Old Navy’s versatility excels in dining rooms. Hale Navy works broadly as an accent.
Availability
Both Old Navy and Hale Navy come in any sheen from matte to high gloss.
Old Navy vs Hale Navy Comparison Chart
| Paint Color | Old Navy 2063-10 | Hale Navy HC-154 |
|---|---|---|
| LRV | 5.13 | 8.36 |
| Undertones | Green navy | Indigo navy |
| Use | Full rooms | Accents |
| Finishes | All sheens | All sheens |
| Style | Contemporary, traditional | Contemporary |
Real-Life Photos: Old Navy vs Hale Navy
Let’s look at real-life images to visualize the differences between Old Navy and Hale Navy:
Benjamin Moore Old Navy
Benjamin Moore Hale Navy
While both deep navy blues, Old Navy appears slightly brighter while Hale Navy looks richer. Light affects their tones.
Should I Choose Old Navy or Hale Navy?
So how do you decide between Benjamin Moore’s Old Navy or Hale Navy for your home? Here are some tips:
Choose Old Navy 2063-10 if you want:
- A green-tinted versatile navy
- A stately backdrop for dining rooms
- A refined, relaxing all-over color
- A flexible navy across varied spaces
Choose Hale Navy HC-154 if you want:
- A deep, dramatic indigo navy
- Striking contrast as an accent
- An intense bold splash of color
- Maximum visual impact
Get large samples of both paint colors. Paint swatches on walls viewing during day and night. This gives the best sense of their undertones and depth.
Also visualize them with decor you already have. The two deep blues suit different aesthetics despite their similarity.
Ideal Room Pairings
Here are some rooms perfectly suited to Old Navy and Hale Navy paint colors:
Benjamin Moore Old Navy
- Dining Rooms
- Studies
- Bathrooms
- Bedrooms
- Kitchens
Benjamin Moore Hale Navy
- Accent Walls
- Small Bathrooms
- Kitchens
- Dining Rooms
- Entryways
While both work throughout the home, the above applications make optimal use of each navy’s unique strengths.
Decorating Ideas and Color Pairings
On their own, Old Navy and Hale Navy make bold statements. Complement them with considered colors and materials:
Old Navy 2063-10 Pairings
- Benjamin Moore Edgecomb Gray
- Benjamin Moore Simply White
- Maple and walnut woods
- Brass and chrome metals
- Crisp white trim
Hale Navy HC-154 Pairings
- Benjamin Moore Chantilly Lace
- Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter
- Soft greys and tans
- White trim and natural wood
- Brass hardware
Old Navy vs Hale Navy – Which is Better?
Which deep navy paint color is the winner for your home – Old Navy or Hale Navy?
Consider Old Navy 2063-10 if you want:
- A green-tinted versatile navy
- A stately backdrop for dining rooms
- A refined, relaxing all-over color
- A flexible navy across varied spaces
Consider Hale Navy HC-154 if you want:
- A deep, dramatic indigo navy
- Striking contrast as an accent
- An intense bold splash of color
- Maximum visual impact
While comparable, Old Navy is more versatile as an all-over color and Hale Navy bolder as an accent. Get samples before deciding. Either rich Benjamin Moore navy you choose will create a beautiful, dramatic look.
Frequently Asked Questions
Still undecided between Old Navy or Hale Navy? Here are answers to common questions:
What are the main differences between Old Navy and Hale Navy?
The main differences are Old Navy’s green undertone and suitability for full rooms vs. Hale Navy’s indigo tone and use as an accent.
What colors complement Old Navy?
Old Navy looks beautiful paired with light blues, warm woods, metallics, and crisp white trim for a refined look.
Can you use Hale Navy in a bathroom?
Yes, Hale Navy would be striking on walls in a bathroom combined with bright white accents for bold contrast.
Is Old Navy suitable for northern exposure?
Yes, Old Navy’s richness at 5.13 LRV can handle a north facing room. Add lighter accents to balance the depth.
Does Hale Navy come in pearl finish?
Yes, the intense Hale Navy is available in any sheen from flat matte to pearl to high gloss semi-gloss.
