Sherwin Williams Shiitake vs Accessible Beige: What’s the Difference?

sherwin williams shiitake vs accessible beige

When searching for the perfect warm, earthy neutral paint color, two great options from Sherwin Williams are Shiitake SW 9173 and Accessible Beige SW 7036. At first glance, these two shades can appear quite similar. But looking closely, there are noticeable differences in depth and undertones.

This in-depth guide will compare Shiitake vs Accessible Beige to help you determine which is better for your home’s interior. We’ll analyze everything from undertones, light reflectance value (LRV), real photos, room pairings, and more.

By the end, you’ll understand how to choose between these beautiful Sherwin Williams neutrals. Let’s dive in!

Key Differences Between Shiitake and Accessible Beige

Before getting into the details, here’s a high-level overview of how Shiitake and Accessible Beige differ:

  • Undertones – Shiitake is a deep brown, Accessible Beige is a medium beige
  • Light Reflectance – Shiitake has an LRV of 51, Accessible Beige has an LRV of 58
  • Use – Shiitake suits accents, Accessible Beige fits backdrops
  • Rooms – Shiitake excels as a focal point, Accessible Beige shines everywhere
  • Availability – Both come in all sheens

Now let’s explore Shiitake SW 9173 and Accessible Beige SW 7036 more thoroughly.

Detailed Review of Shiitake SW 9173

Sherwin Williams Shiitake
Image Credit:@ ashleigh.fordham

With its deep brown appearance, Shiitake SW 9173 by Sherwin Williams creates a dramatic, earthy backdrop or bold accent wall. This dark neutral commands attention.

Here are some key details about Shiitake:

  • LRV: 51
  • Undertones: Deep brown
  • Finish: Available in all sheens
  • Rooms: Accent walls, dining rooms, offices
  • Pairs Well With: Natural tones, wood finishes

Shiitake is a heavily saturated reddish-brown with subtle brick undertones. In certain lights it can read almost black. The deep shade conveys a rugged sophistication.

The 51 light reflectance value provides contrast without being too somber. Shiitake gives off an enveloping, cocooning feel.

This saturated neutral pairs well with warmer beiges and woodsy tones needing grounding. Popular Shiitake color pairings include:

  • Sherwin Williams Accessible Beige
  • Sherwin Williams Evergreens
  • Raw wood finishes
  • Black wrought iron accents
  • Creamy white trims
See also  Behr Sculptor Clay vs BM Revere Pewter: What’s the Difference?

While Shiitake can accent anywhere at home, it truly excels as:

  • An accent wall
  • A dining room statement
  • A bold office backdrop
  • On built-in cabinets and bookshelves

With its deep brown drama, Shiitake makes an impactful earthy accent.

Detailed Review of Accessible Beige SW 7036

Accessible Beige

appearance, Accessible Beige SW 7036 by Sherwin Williams creates a warm, welcoming backdrop that works across styles. This versatile neutral succeeds in both modern and traditional spaces.

Here are some key details about Accessible Beige:

  • LRV: 58
  • Undertones: Medium beige
  • Finish: Available in all sheens
  • Rooms: Living rooms, bedrooms, offices
  • Pairs Well With: Blues, greens, wood tones

Accessible Beige is a relaxed, softened medium beige with faint mushroom undertones. In certain lights it can read as a weathered putty. The versatile neutral has broad appeal.

The 58 light reflectance value prevents the shade from feeling too dark or drab. Accessible Beige strikes a cozy yet bright balance suitable for most rooms.

This adaptable neutral complements both cool and warm accents nicely. Popular Accessible Beige color pairings include:

  • Sherwin Williams Naval
  • Sherwin Williams High Reflective White
  • Crisp white trims
  • Rich walnut wood accents
  • Black iron fixtures

While suitable anywhere at home, Accessible Beige truly excels in these spaces:

  • Living Rooms
  • Bedrooms
  • Offices
  • Dining Rooms
  • Libraries

Accessible Beige’s warmth helps create a welcoming, versatile backdrop, perfect for varied styles.

Light Reflectance Value Comparison

The main difference in LRV between Shiitake and Accessible Beige is significant:

  • Shiitake SW 9173: 51 LRV
  • Accessible Beige SW 7036: 58 LRV

Accessible Beige will read much lighter than the deep, dramatic Shiitake. Accessible Beige provides enough light for an all-over color, while Shiitake is best reserved for bold accents.

Direct Comparison of Undertones

When viewed together, here is how the undertones of Shiitake and Accessible Beige differ:

  • Shiitake is a heavily saturated deep reddish brown that appears nearly black in low light.
  • Accessible Beige is a soft medium beige with distinct mushroom-like qualities.

Shiitake is a bold, dramatic neutral while Accessible Beige is versatile and welcoming.

Style and Room Pairings

Due to its saturated depth, Shiitake SW 9173 excels as:

  • An accent wall
  • A dining room statement
  • A bold office backdrop
  • On built-in cabinets and bookshelves

Accessible Beige SW 7036 fits best as an all-over wall color in these rooms:

  • Living Rooms
  • Bedrooms
  • Offices
  • Dining Rooms
  • Libraries
See also  Silver Satin vs Classic Gray: What’s the Difference?

So Shiitake makes a striking accent, while Accessible Beige shines as a subtle, versatile backdrop.

Real-Life Photo Examples

Let’s look at real-life photos to compare Shiitake and Accessible Beige:

Shiitake SW 9173

Real Sherwin Williams Shiitake
Image Credit:@ copperskydesignremodel

Accessible Beige SW 7036

Real Sherwin Williams Accessible Beige

You can see Shiitake’s deep brown tone compared to the soft beige warmth of Accessible Beige. Lighting affects Shiitake’s saturation.

Should You Choose Shiitake or Accessible Beige?

So when choosing between Sherwin Williams’ Shiitake or Accessible Beige, which works best for your space? Consider the following:

Consider Shiitake SW 9173 if you want:

  • A deep, dramatic reddish-brown
  • To create a bold focal point or accent wall
  • A sophisticated dining room or office splash
  • An earthy, enveloping neutral

Consider Accessible Beige SW 7036 if you want:

  • A soft, welcoming medium beige
  • A versatile shade for entire rooms
  • A cozy but bright living room, bedroom, or dining room
  • A subtle, peaceful wall color

For impact as an accent, choose Shiitake. For a flexible backdrop, go with Accessible Beige.

Get large color samples before deciding. Test them on walls at varied times of day to see undertones.

Either of these beautiful Sherwin Williams browns can meet your needs gorgeously!

Decorating Ideas and Color Pairings

On their own, Shiitake and Accessible Beige create appealing backdrops. Here are ideas to complement them:

Shiitake SW 9173 Pairings

  • Natural materials like jute and linen
  • Creamy whites and antique golds
  • Distressed wood finishes
  • Wrought iron fixtures
  • Retro tile patterns

Accessible Beige SW 7036 Pairings

  • Soothing blue and sage green tones
  • Off-white trims
  • Weathered oak wood accents
  • Black iron lighting
  • Subtle geometric prints

Choosing complementary colors and finishes allows you to make both Shiitake and Accessible Beige shine.

Room-by-Room Guide

Here are rooms best suited to Shiitake and Accessible Beige:

Living Rooms

Shiitake – Striking accent wall behind TVs or furnishings for drama.

Accessible BeigeCozy, welcoming backdrop perfect for family living areas.


ShiitakeBold focal point on a wall behind the bed or bed frame.

Accessible BeigePeaceful and relaxing – promotes restful sleep.

Dining Rooms

ShiitakeRustic dining statement wall that provides visual interest.

Accessible BeigeWarm and hospitable – encourages gathering and conversing.


ShiitakeSophisticated, refined feel for offices requiring focus.

Accessible BeigeCalm and tranquil – reduces office fatigue and stress.

Both neutrals work well but have very different effects based on use.

See also  Fog Mist vs Pale Oak: What’s the Difference?

Shiitake vs. Accessible Beige Comparison Chart

Here is a summary comparison between Shiitake SW 9173 and Accessible Beige SW 7036:

Paint Color Shiitake SW 9173 Accessible Beige SW 7036
LRV 51 58
Undertone Deep brown Medium beige
Use Accents All-over color
Sheen All finishes All finishes
Rooms Dining, offices Living, bedrooms

Which Neutral is Best for Your Home?

So which of these beautiful Sherwin Williams browns works best in your space?

Shiitake SW 9173 is the better choice if you:

  • Want a bold, dramatic brown focal point
  • Are seeking an earthy neutral with red undertones
  • Need a striking dining room or office accent
  • Prefer deep, enveloping wall colors

Accessible Beige SW 7036 is ideal if you:

  • Are looking for a welcoming beige neutral
  • Want a versatile shade for entire rooms
  • Need a peaceful living room, bedroom, or dining room
  • Prefer subtle, flexible wall colors

For impact as an accent, go with Shiitake. For a cozy backdrop, choose Accessible Beige.

Be sure to get large color samples before deciding – both are stunning!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Here are answers to common questions about Shiitake and Accessible Beige:

Q: How do Shiitake and Accessible Beige differ?

A: Shiitake is a deep brown accent while Accessible Beige is a soft beige wall color. Shiitake is bold and Accessible Beige is subtle.

Q: Which paint color is darker?

A: Shiitake SW 9173 has an LRV of 51, while Accessible Beige SW 7036 has an LRV of 58, making Shiitake much darker.

Q: What colors go with Shiitake?

A: Creamy whites, antique golds, natural materials like jute and linen, and wrought iron accents complement Shiitake’s depth.

Q: Is Accessible Beige too dark for a dim room?

A: No, with an LRV of 58 Accessible Beige can brighten up a dim room without being too dark when used all over walls.

Q: Does Shiitake have gray tones?

A: No, Shiitake SW 9173 is a true deep brown without significant gray undertones.


Whether you choose the bold drama of Shiitake SW 9173 or the subtle versatility of Accessible Beige SW 7036, both of these Sherwin Williams neutrals are beautiful.

Test them out to find the perfect neutral for your needs and style!

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 5 / 5. Vote count: 2

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.