When searching for the perfect black paint color, it’s easy to get stuck comparing two similar deep shades from Sherwin Williams. Popular choices Tricorn Black SW 6258 and Black Magic SW 6991 appear identical at first glance. But what really differentiates these two rich, dark blacks?
In this in-depth guide, we’ll analyze Tricorn Black vs Black Magic to help you determine the ideal black paint for your home. We’ll look at undertones, light reflectance, real-life photos, room pairings and more.
Table of Contents
Key Differences Between Tricorn Black and Black Magic
Before getting into the details, here is an overview of the main differences between Sherwin Williams’ Tricorn Black and Black Magic:
- Undertones – Tricorn Black is a warm black, Black Magic is a cool black
- Light Reflectance – Both have an LRV of 3
- Use – Tricorn Black suits traditional styles, Black Magic fits modern decor
- Rooms – Tricorn Black excels in dining rooms, Black Magic shines in offices
- Availability – Both come in all sheens
Now let’s explore Tricorn Black and Black Magic more thoroughly.
Sherwin Williams Tricorn Black SW 6258
With its deep warm black appearance, Sherwin Williams Tricorn Black SW 6258 makes a dramatic statement well-suited for accentuating traditional and transitional styles. This versatile black works in both formal and casual spaces.
Here are some details about Tricorn Black:
- LRV: 3
- Undertones: Warm black
- Finish: Available in all sheens
- Rooms: Dining rooms, bedrooms, offices, theaters
- Pairs Well With: Golds, creams, wood tones
Tricorn Black is a rich, charcoal black with faint brown undertones. In certain lights it can read as true black. The dramatic black has traditional appeal.
The 3 light reflectance value makes this close to true black without being flat and lifeless. Tricorn Black has depth.
This versatile black complements both cool and warm accents nicely. Popular Tricorn Black color pairings include:
- Sherwin Williams Online
- Brushed gold accents
- Cream upholstery
- Walnut wood finishes
While suitable anywhere at home, Tricorn Black truly excels in these spaces:
- Dining Rooms
- Bedrooms
- Offices
- Theaters
- Libraries
Tricorn Black’s warmth helps create a dramatic yet welcoming feel perfect for traditional styles. Use it to make bold statements.
Sherwin Williams Black Magic SW 6991
With its crisp cool black appearance, Sherwin Williams Black Magic SW 6991 makes a dramatic statement well-suited for accentuating contemporary styles. This versatile black works across modern spaces.
Here are some details about Black Magic:
- LRV: 3
- Undertones: Cool black
- Finish: Available in all sheens
- Rooms: Offices, dining rooms, kitchens, bathrooms
- Pairs Well With: Silvers, whites, grays
Black Magic is a rich, solid black with a subtle blue undertone. In all lighting it maintains a true, consistent black appearance.
The 3 light reflectance value makes this close to true black without being dull or flat. Black Magic has crisp definition.
This adaptable black complements both bold and muted colors nicely. Popular Black Magic color pairings include:
- Sherwin Williams Online
- Polished chrome accents
- Crisp white trim
- Gray upholstery
While suitable anywhere at home, Black Magic truly excels in these dramatic modern spaces:
- Offices
- Dining Rooms
- Kitchens
- Bathrooms
- Theaters
Black Magic’s crispness helps create a sleek, contemporary feel perfect for bold modern statements.
Comparing Tricorn Black vs Black Magic
Now that we’ve examined Tricorn Black and Black Magic independently, let’s directly compare them:
Light Reflectance
Tricorn Black and Black Magic have the same LRV of 3. They will appear identical in terms of depth and richness.
Undertones
Here’s where the main difference lies. Tricorn Black is a warm black, while Black Magic is a cooler black.
Use & Rooms
Tricorn Black’s warmth excels in traditional dining rooms. Black Magic’s coolness is perfect for modern offices.
Availability
Both Tricorn Black and Black Magic come in any sheen from matte to high gloss.
| Paint Color | Tricorn Black SW 6258 | Black Magic SW 6991 |
|---|---|---|
| LRV | 3 | 3 |
| Undertones | Warm black | Cool black |
| Use | Traditional styles | Modern decor |
| Finishes | All sheens | All sheens |
| Style | Traditional | Contemporary |
Real-Life Photos: Tricorn Black vs Black Magic
Let’s look at real-life photos to better visualize the subtle differences between Tricorn Black and Black Magic:
Sherwin Williams Tricorn Black
Sherwin Williams Black Magic
While hard to distinguish, Tricorn Black generally has slightly warmer brown undertones compared to the subtle cool edge of Black Magic. But lighting affects their look.
Should I Choose Tricorn Black or Black Magic?
So how do you decide between Sherwin Williams’ Tricorn Black or Black Magic for your home? Here are some tips:
Choose Tricorn Black SW 6258 if you want:
- A dramatic warm black
- A versatile black suitable for traditional styles
- A black with depth perfect for dining rooms
- To allow metals and woods to pop
Choose Black Magic SW 6991 if you want:
- A dramatic cool black
- A versatile black suitable for modern spaces
- A true black perfect for offices and baths
- A crisp black to allow colors to stand out
Get samples of both Tricorn Black and Black Magic. Paint large swatches on your walls viewing at different times of day. This gives you the best sense of their subtle undertones.
You can also pair them with decor you already have to visualize the look. Both offer dramatic deep black tones that suit varied styles.
Ideal Room Pairings
Here are some rooms that are especially well-suited to Tricorn Black and Black Magic paint colors:
Sherwin Williams Tricorn Black
- Dining Rooms
- Bedrooms
- Offices
- Theaters
- Libraries
Sherwin Williams Black Magic
- Offices
- Kitchens
- Bathrooms
- Dining Rooms
- Theaters
While both blacks work well throughout the home, the above applications make optimal use of their unique strengths.
Decorating Ideas and Color Pairings
On their own, Tricorn Black and Black Magic make dramatic statements. Complement them with other colors and materials for gorgeous spaces:
Tricorn Black SW 6258 Pairings
- Sherwin Williams Online
- Brushed gold accents
- Cream upholstery
- Walnut wood finishes
Black Magic SW 6991 Pairings
- Sherwin Williams Online
- Polished chrome accents
- Crisp white trim
- Gray upholstery
Tricorn Black vs Black Magic – Which is Better?
So which black paint color is better for your home – Tricorn Black or Black Magic?
Consider Tricorn Black SW 6258 if you want:
- A dramatic warm black
- A versatile black suitable for traditional styles
- A black with depth perfect for dining rooms
- To allow metals and woods to pop
Consider Black Magic SW 6991 if you want:
- A dramatic cool black
- A versatile black suitable for modern spaces
- A true black perfect for offices and baths
- A crisp black to allow colors to stand out
While Tricorn Black offers warmth, Black Magic provides modern edge. Get samples before deciding. Either rich Sherwin Williams black you choose will lend beautiful drama.
Frequently Asked Questions
Still trying to decide between Tricorn Black or Black Magic? Here are answers to some common questions:
What are the main differences between Tricorn Black and Black Magic?
The main subtle difference is their undertones. Tricorn Black is a warm black while Black Magic is a slightly cooler black.
What colors go well with Black Magic?
Black Magic looks beautiful paired with crisp whites, chrome accents, grays, and silver tones for sleek contrast.
Can you use Tricorn Black in a bathroom?
Yes, Tricorn Black’s warmth would complement marble, gold accents, and cream tiles nicely in a bathroom.
Is Black Magic suitable for southern exposure?
Yes, Black Magic’s subtle coolness helps temper the warm light from southern sun exposure.
Does Tricorn Black come in eggshell finish?
Yes, Tricorn Black is extremely versatile and comes in any sheen from flat matte to high gloss eggshell.
